A Few Summer Bonsai
+4
Kevin S - Wisco Bonsai
bilbo
AlainK
thomasj
8 posters
Page 1 of 1
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
VERY NICE TREES, especially those pines.
But I confess to being confused.
Since I'm new to bonsai, I tend to ask a lot of questions on some topics and one of the topics is my own procumbens.
Several different independent mentors have told me with great confidence, that procumbens will not graduate to the mature growth, but always stay with the juvenile foliage.
This topic has come up frequently with various mentors and myself me because I have expressed concern at my perceived need to perform some growing tip pinches (if for no other reason than to keep the foliage juvenile).
And yet, without exception, each one has relied "oh, you don't have to worry about that with a procumbens, they'll always stay juvenile."
And then here you are posting pics of a Juniperus, clearly graduated to mature growth (almost 100%) and you call it a "procumbens."
So, are you certain this is a procumbens?
Is there zero chance it could be some other Juniperus?
I can see legitimate differences of opinion with tools, or technique, but actual tree taxonomy should, I would think, be fairly standard.
But I confess to being confused.
Since I'm new to bonsai, I tend to ask a lot of questions on some topics and one of the topics is my own procumbens.
Several different independent mentors have told me with great confidence, that procumbens will not graduate to the mature growth, but always stay with the juvenile foliage.
This topic has come up frequently with various mentors and myself me because I have expressed concern at my perceived need to perform some growing tip pinches (if for no other reason than to keep the foliage juvenile).
And yet, without exception, each one has relied "oh, you don't have to worry about that with a procumbens, they'll always stay juvenile."
And then here you are posting pics of a Juniperus, clearly graduated to mature growth (almost 100%) and you call it a "procumbens."
So, are you certain this is a procumbens?
Is there zero chance it could be some other Juniperus?
I can see legitimate differences of opinion with tools, or technique, but actual tree taxonomy should, I would think, be fairly standard.
bilbo- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
I hate to say this but whoever gave you that info was wrong as procumbens for sure will give you mature growth as seen in my previous pic and this one. Constant pinching will allow this to happen. I've been working with procumbens since 2002 and every one of them has the scale or what you would call mature foliage. Some people say never to pinch junipers and that's probably because they were doing it wrong and weakened the branch or the tree too much. My procumbens speak for themselves pretty much. It will take a few years but it will turn to mature needles, and sometime for whatever reason will revert back to juvenile foliage, but I think this might be from too much fertilizing.
thomasj- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
I apologize if this distracts the post with your terrific trees, but I'm very curious on your last comments.
"Some people say never to pinch junipers and that's probably because they were doing it wrong and weakened the branch or the tree too much"
What is the correct way to pinch Juniperus?
Do you know of any resources or videos?
Is there a way to prevent/delay the foliage from advancing to "scale" (mature)?
Personally, I prefer the juvenile foliage and had the impression that by keeping the tips pinched, I could increase ramification and retain juvenile foliage.
At our club's Dallas convention last April, there was a beautiful 30 year old procumbens but had 100% juvenile foliage.
"Some people say never to pinch junipers and that's probably because they were doing it wrong and weakened the branch or the tree too much"
What is the correct way to pinch Juniperus?
Do you know of any resources or videos?
Is there a way to prevent/delay the foliage from advancing to "scale" (mature)?
Personally, I prefer the juvenile foliage and had the impression that by keeping the tips pinched, I could increase ramification and retain juvenile foliage.
At our club's Dallas convention last April, there was a beautiful 30 year old procumbens but had 100% juvenile foliage.
bilbo- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
Hi there, I'm from Wylie and was a former member of the Dallas club many years ago. In fact I was the one who made those white curtains behind the show trees. As to your question about the juvenile foliage, the only thing that might work is rather than pinching you might try cutting the tips deep inside like many people say todo rather than pinching. I have seen some older procumbens that went to mature foliage even though no one worked on them. Try the scissor cutting method and see what happens. :-)
thomasj- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
Very nice tree.
There is probably still some work to do on it, but it already looks good
There is probably still some work to do on it, but it already looks good
AlainK- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
junipers should really never be constantly pinched back...
doing so gives them the message that they might as well just give up and die
(putting it in simple terms)
rather they should be allowed a vigorous growth period before cutting/pinching back...
so even a "finished" tree will be allowed to look like a punk for a while before being reigned back into conforming with the masses.
and juvenile delinquent foliage is usually produced as a reaction to stress.
nice looking trees !
doing so gives them the message that they might as well just give up and die
(putting it in simple terms)
rather they should be allowed a vigorous growth period before cutting/pinching back...
so even a "finished" tree will be allowed to look like a punk for a while before being reigned back into conforming with the masses.
and juvenile delinquent foliage is usually produced as a reaction to stress.
nice looking trees !
Kevin S - Wisco Bonsai- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
junipers should really never be constantly pinched back... doing so gives them the message that they might as well just give up and die wrote:
I have to disagree with this. The last pic I provided is from a juniper I bought in 1998 and still have today. MY junipers have never looked stressed out or in poor health as to want to just give up and die. Once the new mature foliage comes in pinching is not required anymore except for the occasional pinch here and there to keep the shape .
thomasj- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
they dont get that message overnite... or even perhaps in a decade... but eventually they do.
that is supported by newer research and science.
matter of fact, much of the new thinking is worthy of consideration.
didnt wanna hi-jack your thread, so all i am saying is that for anyone new, question what you have been told.
that is supported by newer research and science.
matter of fact, much of the new thinking is worthy of consideration.
didnt wanna hi-jack your thread, so all i am saying is that for anyone new, question what you have been told.
Kevin S - Wisco Bonsai- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
In fact there is much of misinformation regarding constantly pinching junipers... outdated techniques... confusing terminology.kevin stoeveken wrote:... ...that is supported by newer research and science... ...
Brian v. Fleet, Michael Haegedorn, Ryan Neil, Walter Pall, Boon Manakitivipart, Bjorn Bjorholm, etc, etc, are some of the renowned artists/artisans who do not pinch junipers any more!
my nellie- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
Add Peter Tea to that list, his explanation was that new growth is...well...the newest..., most efficient and productive. Repetitive pinching costs a plant a lot of energy. Apparently it is healthier to snip older, small side branches and let back budding occur, and hold on to that precious new growth at the tips.
Precarious- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
I'm VERY SORRY for what happened to your thread with your great trees.
I could have, and should have started a different thread and invited your insights there on that topic.
I'll try to find time tomorrow to do that as I do find these are all great comments from knowledgeable people, and it is interesting regarding Juniperus, but this thread should be dedicated to you great trees.
I could have, and should have started a different thread and invited your insights there on that topic.
I'll try to find time tomorrow to do that as I do find these are all great comments from knowledgeable people, and it is interesting regarding Juniperus, but this thread should be dedicated to you great trees.
bilbo- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
Anybody care to present THEIR Junipers? You know, to compare/contrast the two different approaches.
It would seem to me that thomasj has a pretty decent grasp on how to care for his trees.
Anyone?
It would seem to me that thomasj has a pretty decent grasp on how to care for his trees.
Anyone?
LanceMac10- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
Beautiful trees !
Hmm, the ugly rears it head -------
[1] The problem of Experienced growing versus the Japanese trained masters.
[2] This how we deal with it in Fine Art
- when you have gone away for 3 to 5 years [ or more or less ] and cleared your head, done enough to
show that you are not a clone, folk may begin to take you seriously.
This might take longer with growing, as opposed to sketches and painted efforts.
The trees are beautiful, and if there is a flaw in the technique, then you depend on Honesty, and Truth.
I am seeing a lot of this as the Internet takes over more and more.
Value experience and visual evidence and not talk.
Action always speaks louder than words.
Laters.
Khaimraj
Hmm, the ugly rears it head -------
[1] The problem of Experienced growing versus the Japanese trained masters.
[2] This how we deal with it in Fine Art
- when you have gone away for 3 to 5 years [ or more or less ] and cleared your head, done enough to
show that you are not a clone, folk may begin to take you seriously.
This might take longer with growing, as opposed to sketches and painted efforts.
The trees are beautiful, and if there is a flaw in the technique, then you depend on Honesty, and Truth.
I am seeing a lot of this as the Internet takes over more and more.
Value experience and visual evidence and not talk.
Action always speaks louder than words.
Laters.
Khaimraj
Khaimraj Seepersad- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
Oh Lance,
my junipers [ 3 ] suck.
Sorry, no images to present.
Until
Khaimraj
my junipers [ 3 ] suck.
Sorry, no images to present.
Until
Khaimraj
Khaimraj Seepersad- Member
Re: A Few Summer Bonsai
good job on recovery lance !!!!
planning some big work on one of mine... will try to remember to get pics on the blog...
planning some big work on one of mine... will try to remember to get pics on the blog...
Kevin S - Wisco Bonsai- Member
Similar topics
» Valavanis Summer Shohin Bonsai Displays
» Conifer Bonsai in Valavanis' Summer Garden
» SOME LATE SUMMER BONSAI FUN DURING A SMALL WORKSHOP IN MY GARDEN.
» Summer Work on Ficus Bonsai
» Bonsai and garden - early summer view
» Conifer Bonsai in Valavanis' Summer Garden
» SOME LATE SUMMER BONSAI FUN DURING A SMALL WORKSHOP IN MY GARDEN.
» Summer Work on Ficus Bonsai
» Bonsai and garden - early summer view
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum