Mystery Tree Help please
+8
David Brunner
GašperG
Laughing Buddha
arihato
augustine
bonsaisr
abcd
Michael Cooper
12 posters
Page 1 of 1
Mystery Tree Help please
One of the members of our club sadly passed away and the trees were distributed amongst us. They had been neglected and it is thought that some may have come from warmer climates so I rather interested to know if any on has any ideas about this one I acquired. The tree which was dead was a spindly thing about a foot high with quite a spreading structure.At its base it is growing new leaves which have a curious little feature at the bottom of the petiole,two little curly stipules? Is that any clue to identification? It may be something quite exotic or very mundane I don't know, neither did any of our members who have a lot more knowledge than me. So any suggestions are welcome.
If it is from warmer climes I would like to know before the temperature starts to go down much further and autumn takes hold.



If it is from warmer climes I would like to know before the temperature starts to go down much further and autumn takes hold.



Michael Cooper- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Forsythia came to my mind at first but Forsythia does not have those curly little stipules and according to my book F.leavves should be opposite each other whereas these are not. Thanks for helping everyone
Michael Cooper- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Maybe Chinese Quince,Pseudocydonia sinensis.
Or possibly an Escallonia ?.
Or possibly an Escallonia ?.
Laughing Buddha- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Hello Micheal – I too think it is a pear, it looks like Pyrus pyrifolia. The young or juvenile leaves of many trees have much more heavily serrated margins that leaves on mature branches.
I don’t think it is quince as their stipules are fairly large and rounded, not small and needle-shaped like your tree.
I’m sorry about the passing of your club member, and good luck with the tree. Time will reveal its identity with much greater certainty.
David B.
I don’t think it is quince as their stipules are fairly large and rounded, not small and needle-shaped like your tree.
I’m sorry about the passing of your club member, and good luck with the tree. Time will reveal its identity with much greater certainty.
David B.
David Brunner- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Thanks for all your suggestions folks,just looking forward to see what it might be one day.Having been told that many of his trees came from hotter climates I shall perhaps take it in under shelter when the nights get colder.
Michael Cooper- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Michael Cooper wrote:One of the members of our club sadly passed away and the trees were distributed amongst us. They had been neglected and it is thought that some may have come from warmer climates so I rather interested to know if any on has any ideas about this one I acquired. The tree which was dead was a spindly thing about a foot high with quite a spreading structure.At its base it is growing new leaves which have a curious little feature at the bottom of the petiole,two little curly stipules? Is that any clue to identification? It may be something quite exotic or very mundane I don't know, neither did any of our members who have a lot more knowledge than me. So any suggestions are welcome.
If it is from warmer climes I would like to know before the temperature starts to go down much further and autumn takes hold.
New growth this year might help make it easier



I have just let it grow with only a little trimming, now about a foot high,left it iust to see what it might be.It has very sharp thorns now.
Any idea anyone?
Michael Cooper- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Quite a few pear varieties and their rootstocks also have thorns........
JT MKBonsai
JT MKBonsai
MKBonsai- Member
Mystery Tree
It does not look like a tropical. To be safe, I would let it have a cool rest just above freezing for the winter. Then next year feed it heavily and let it grow wild until it blooms. Don't you have some sort of agricultural extension service or a nearby university that can identify it?
Iris
Iris
bonsaisr- Member
Re: Mystery Tree Help please
Thanks folks that is food for thought. Probably have to wait till it blooms one day, mind you one of the suggestions means that will be another five years!
Its main features I think to bear in mind are the finely serrated leave and now sharp the thorns
Its main features I think to bear in mind are the finely serrated leave and now sharp the thorns
Michael Cooper- Member
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|