Tsuga canadensis 'pendulata' Is this worth digging for bonsai or penjing?
4 posters
Page 1 of 1
Tsuga canadensis 'pendulata' Is this worth digging for bonsai or penjing?
I have had this weeping hemlock for approx 12 years. I originally bought it for bonsia material. After a couple of years, I decided to put it in the ground with thoughts that it would better serve as a landscape tree. the trunk has thickened a lot and I keep looking at it wondering. It is approx 95 cm tall, 1.2 meters wide.
Here are some photos. What do you think about this tree? Does it have potential to be a good tree?
Front as planted
Closer view
Ground level
Another shot
Another angle
Here are some photos. What do you think about this tree? Does it have potential to be a good tree?
Front as planted
Closer view
Ground level
Another shot
Another angle
Last edited by Todd Ellis on Mon Aug 02, 2010 12:12 am; edited 1 time in total
Todd Ellis- Member
Re: Tsuga canadensis 'pendulata' Is this worth digging for bonsai or penjing?
It is hard to tell from the pictures, so I don't yet have an opinion. Exposing the nebari may help you decide which direction to take.
I can, however, see that like with most T. canadensis, it is quite leggy. If you do decide to dig this, I would prepare it by doing some hard pruning a year or two before digging. Eastern hemlock do not bud back well, especially in pots. The best budding you will see is on a vigorous tree in the ground, so take advantage of it while you can.
Otherwise, it is a lovely little landscape specimen!
Cheers
I can, however, see that like with most T. canadensis, it is quite leggy. If you do decide to dig this, I would prepare it by doing some hard pruning a year or two before digging. Eastern hemlock do not bud back well, especially in pots. The best budding you will see is on a vigorous tree in the ground, so take advantage of it while you can.
Otherwise, it is a lovely little landscape specimen!
Cheers
LSBonsai- Member
Re: Tsuga canadensis 'pendulata' Is this worth digging for bonsai or penjing?
Hey Todd,
It is good that you are seeking opinions but the bottom line is that if you don't/can't see a "good" tree here than it never will be one. In my experience, in most cases when looking at this kind of material for potential the tree either jumps out at you or it doesn't. I am not one of these amazing artists (read...Bill V, Walter, Suthin, Pavel, etc..) that can take very little and making something nice from it..for me its either obviously there or its not.
From what I can see in these pictures, this particular material would remain in my landscape. At this point in my bonsai life I just don't have the time or energy to put toward less than ideal material...but that is just me:)
For what its worth:)
John
It is good that you are seeking opinions but the bottom line is that if you don't/can't see a "good" tree here than it never will be one. In my experience, in most cases when looking at this kind of material for potential the tree either jumps out at you or it doesn't. I am not one of these amazing artists (read...Bill V, Walter, Suthin, Pavel, etc..) that can take very little and making something nice from it..for me its either obviously there or its not.
From what I can see in these pictures, this particular material would remain in my landscape. At this point in my bonsai life I just don't have the time or energy to put toward less than ideal material...but that is just me:)
For what its worth:)
John
jgeanangel- Member
Re: Tsuga canadensis 'pendulata' Is this worth digging for bonsai or penjing?
I'd tend toward John's opinion.
JimLewis- Member
Similar topics
» tsuga canadensis
» Collected Eastern Hemlock (Tsuga canadensis)
» bonsai-penjing:winter compositions
» Bonsai Shari SiDiao books worth price?
» When does the tree become "Bonsai" or "Penjing"?
» Collected Eastern Hemlock (Tsuga canadensis)
» bonsai-penjing:winter compositions
» Bonsai Shari SiDiao books worth price?
» When does the tree become "Bonsai" or "Penjing"?
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum