ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
+9
Todd Ellis
Hawaiian77
Geof
John Quinn
jgeanangel
Rick Moquin
pine queen
bumblebee
mike page
13 posters
Page 1 of 1
ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
I acquired the rock about 16 years ago, and the San Jose Juniper about 20 years ago. The juni was 5 gallon nursery stock, and has been attached to the base of the rock for about 15 years. The roots grow into the pot, and can be easily trimmed by lifting the rock from the pot.
Today I repotted tree and rock into this Sara Rayner pot. Height including pot is 24 inches.
Today I repotted tree and rock into this Sara Rayner pot. Height including pot is 24 inches.
mike page- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Its beautiful. How do you keep the rock from falling over?
Libby
Libby
bumblebee- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
There is a broom stick that passes through the table, up through the pot and through the rock. Am I getting warm? Beautiful look!
Q
Q
pine queen- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
This is "transformer" not bonsai.
These are crude observation, but there is absolutely no balance in the entire composition. The rock overwhelms the entire composition, altough it should mesh with the tree, it overpowers it.
If you enjoy this composition, then that it all that matters.
These are crude observation, but there is absolutely no balance in the entire composition. The rock overwhelms the entire composition, altough it should mesh with the tree, it overpowers it.
If you enjoy this composition, then that it all that matters.
Last edited by Rick Moquin on Sun Feb 07, 2010 9:08 pm; edited 1 time in total
Rick Moquin- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
"Beauty in things exists merely in the mind which contemplates them" David Hume
I see a fantastic precipice cliff (rock) that scales in well in texture with a tree that has done its best to grow under challenging circumstances but still manages some grace. Sarah would be proud to see this effort. Thanks for showing!
Q
I see a fantastic precipice cliff (rock) that scales in well in texture with a tree that has done its best to grow under challenging circumstances but still manages some grace. Sarah would be proud to see this effort. Thanks for showing!
Q
pine queen- Member
Grace and decency
Rick Moquin wrote:
Another waste of a beautiful Sarah Rayner IMO.
Hey Mike, Thanks for sharing...I always appreciate the level of detail in your work and your photography!!
John
Rick...I noticed that you left off the "H" from the end of your statement quoted above...but then again it appears to be missing from your implied intent as well???
jgeanangel- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Thanks all for your comments, pro and con.
Libby, to answer your question; The rock can stand on it's own, even out of the pot as it is fairly flat on the bottom. In this case, it's wired to the pot though the drain holes using #12 copper wire. It's very stable.
Mike
Libby, to answer your question; The rock can stand on it's own, even out of the pot as it is fairly flat on the bottom. In this case, it's wired to the pot though the drain holes using #12 copper wire. It's very stable.
Mike
mike page- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
[quote="Rick Moquin"]This is "transformer" not bonsai. quote]
Rick, you don't like the rock planting, and that's ok. But one thing has been bugging me, so I must ask. What the hell is a "transformer"? As an old electrician I know the word as it applies to voltage, but understanding it's use in this case eludes me. Please explain. Thanks.
Mike
Rick, you don't like the rock planting, and that's ok. But one thing has been bugging me, so I must ask. What the hell is a "transformer"? As an old electrician I know the word as it applies to voltage, but understanding it's use in this case eludes me. Please explain. Thanks.
Mike
mike page- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Howzit Mike,
Very interesting composition. I would like to see more branches to may be a cascade but really liking the bonsai pot.
-Tim
Very interesting composition. I would like to see more branches to may be a cascade but really liking the bonsai pot.
-Tim
Hawaiian77- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Mike, was there die-back on this tree between 2004 - current? I like the fuller tree "before" compared to the newer minimal (foliage pads) look. Or, did you try to make the tree look older by reducing the number of foliage pads? Or was there another reason? Where did you find that beautiful rock? The pot is perfect for the rock! Great composition. Regards, Todd
Todd Ellis- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Hmm, for some reasons I agree with Rick. I personally feel that the composition is kind of weird. The "weight" of the rock seems like it is "crushing" on the tree itself, and my first impression/visual was that it doesnt seem right/natural. I just cant help feeling the "weight" itself feels weird. Maybe it's just me and Rick perhaps?
sixhunter- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
G'day Mike and all...
To me, this is the classic depiction of the fight for survival...and less foliage is better...it shouldn't look like it just came from the hairdresser. Furthermore, the rock SHOULD overwhelm the tree. And, the pot works very well...
Outstanding my friend...
IMAFMHO (InMyAncientFeebleMindedHumbleOpinion)…
Pat…mounted on my trusty stead, riding off wildly in all directions…
To me, this is the classic depiction of the fight for survival...and less foliage is better...it shouldn't look like it just came from the hairdresser. Furthermore, the rock SHOULD overwhelm the tree. And, the pot works very well...
Outstanding my friend...
IMAFMHO (InMyAncientFeebleMindedHumbleOpinion)…
Pat…mounted on my trusty stead, riding off wildly in all directions…
bonsaistud- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
bonsaistud wrote:G'day Mike and all...
To me, this is the classic depiction of the fight for survival...and less foliage is better...it shouldn't look like it just came from the hairdresser. Furthermore, the rock SHOULD overwhelm the tree. And, the pot works very well...
Outstanding my friend...
IMAFMHO (InMyAncientFeebleMindedHumbleOpinion)…
Pat…mounted on my trusty stead, riding off wildly in all directions…
Thanks Pat. You have the correct view. The mountain is always large and the tree is small.
In this cass the viewer should imagine the rock as being much larger than it appears in the picture. Bonsai is about imagination. Following is a haiku I posted on another site. It may be appropriate here, with a minor change I made to line 3.
IMAGINATION
A JOURNEY WITHIN THE MIND
A TRUTH DISCOVERED
Last edited by mike page on Sun Apr 11, 2010 12:34 am; edited 1 time in total
mike page- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
"Every picture tells a story" or so the song by Rod Steward goes. This tree and the rock to which it clings to tells of a story very common to the mountains. A story that is very similar to stories that inspired Zen Monks and Sumi-e Painters of ancient Japan. The story of persistence, survival amidst odds and grace under pressure.
The large overbearing rock, the feeble tree with its sparse foliage, clinging onto the rock for dear life, is almost a real life picture of what one often finds in the mountains.
A story very well told indeed and something very similar to Mike's own in the last couple of years.
Keep it up Mike...
The large overbearing rock, the feeble tree with its sparse foliage, clinging onto the rock for dear life, is almost a real life picture of what one often finds in the mountains.
A story very well told indeed and something very similar to Mike's own in the last couple of years.
Keep it up Mike...
Ravi Kiran- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Ravi Kiran wrote:"Every picture tells a story" or so the song by Rod Steward goes. This tree and the rock to which it clings to tells of a story very common to the mountains. A story that is very similar to stories that inspired Zen Monks and Sumi-e Painters of ancient Japan. The story of persistence, survival amidst odds and grace under pressure.
The large overbearing rock, the feeble tree with its sparse foliage, clinging onto the rock for dear life, is almost a real life picture of what one often finds in the mountains.
A story very well told indeed and something very similar to Mike's own in the last couple of years.
Keep it up Mike...
Thanks, Ravi. Your comments are very much appreciated.
Mike
mike page- Member
Hmmm
I like the current trunk line along with the foliage from the 2004 photo.
Actually, I'd prefer the foliage silhouette from 2004 with the trunk line and smaller foliage density of the current tree. I'd reduce the current density, then wire the remaining foliage to resemble the older image.
But that's just me...
BTW Mike, are you coming to Bill V's 2nd U.S. National Bonsai Exhibition?
Actually, I'd prefer the foliage silhouette from 2004 with the trunk line and smaller foliage density of the current tree. I'd reduce the current density, then wire the remaining foliage to resemble the older image.
But that's just me...
BTW Mike, are you coming to Bill V's 2nd U.S. National Bonsai Exhibition?
Mike Pollock- Member
Re: ROCK PLANTING REPOTTED
Mike Pollock wrote:.
BTW Mike, are you coming to Bill V's 2nd U.S. National Bonsai Exhibition?
Mike
I haven't made up my mind yet, but probably not. Airfare from the West Coast to Rochester is big bucks. But, it's still in the "maybe" category.
mike page- Member
Similar topics
» Repotted Rock Planting
» Root over rock/Clinging to rock- watering and inspection of planting made easy.
» DRAGON ROCK repotted
» ROCK PLANTING
» A Tall Rock Planting
» Root over rock/Clinging to rock- watering and inspection of planting made easy.
» DRAGON ROCK repotted
» ROCK PLANTING
» A Tall Rock Planting
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum