Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
+45
AdamJonas
magoca
Bonzi
Nigel Parke
Neli
Nemphis
amazonida
leatherback
Speakergod
BonsaiJim
blackrose
dorothy7774
bingregory
davidlpf
bucknbonsai
rock
Gary Swiech
marcus watts
coh
Lnatural
John Quinn
Jesse
guy ward
pongsatorn.k
Seth Ellwood
Ryan
snobird
Mike Jones
rexman
ogi uyehara
ogie
GerhardGerber
mokster
slowly but surely
Pavel Slovák
Albert Ward
Russell Coker
hirow08
Mr. Moody
moyogijohn
littleart-fx
Jim McIntyre
fiona
Ian Young
Storm
49 posters
Page 1 of 5
Page 1 of 5 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Wow. Really nice progression series. As a newbie, I really appreciate the opportunity to see development like this. Thanks for the effort!
slowly but surely- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Hi Sankofabonsai
Loved to see all the photos, a very good job.
The low left branch is a bit low, but without, the tree loose ballance. I dont think it is enough to grow the next left branch bigger. It still have a ballance-problem.
I would cut off the right branch too, and make a new airlayering, further up the trunk.
Kind regards Yvonne
Loved to see all the photos, a very good job.
The low left branch is a bit low, but without, the tree loose ballance. I dont think it is enough to grow the next left branch bigger. It still have a ballance-problem.
I would cut off the right branch too, and make a new airlayering, further up the trunk.
Kind regards Yvonne
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Excellent stuff! I was having trouble figuring out how to rootwork one of my trees and you cleared it right up with this progression series.
Bravo!
Bravo!
mokster- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Thanks ever so much, just what I needed to see!
Great work and excellent progression.
Cheers
Gerhard
Great work and excellent progression.
Cheers
Gerhard
GerhardGerber- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Hi Sankofabonsai,
Great tree there's more potential to come,is the back portion worth making it as a front for you?just a thought.. Hope things are well with you.Thanks for sharing
Your friend,
Alex/Ogie
Great tree there's more potential to come,is the back portion worth making it as a front for you?just a thought.. Hope things are well with you.Thanks for sharing
Your friend,
Alex/Ogie
ogie- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
really no need for words, the pictures speak for themselves on this 5-year journey. excellent documentation and of course the progression.
if it were me, i'll keep the first left branch...
if it were me, i'll keep the first left branch...
rexman- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
.
Last edited by David Cortizas on Fri Dec 18, 2015 4:42 pm; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Hi Sankofabonsai
Your reply is very good. I thought you allready had cut off the first branch, and it was too late. Your tree will look a lot like the japanese tree in the future, this is good.
Your small trees are also very nice.
Kind regards Yvonne
Your reply is very good. I thought you allready had cut off the first branch, and it was too late. Your tree will look a lot like the japanese tree in the future, this is good.
Your small trees are also very nice.
Kind regards Yvonne
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
.
Last edited by David Cortizas on Fri Dec 18, 2015 4:42 pm; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
I really enjoyed this and the quality of pictures too was great.
Mike
Mike
Mike Jones- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
My only critisism and I would keep the branch on the left, is the general branch placement. It is styled like a Pine with the branches on a horizontal plane. Compare it to the Japanese Elm which has a more vertical habit.
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
.
Last edited by David Cortizas on Fri Dec 18, 2015 4:42 pm; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Sankofabonsai wrote:... bonsai design is matter of likes...
Thanks!
Thats what I like about it as well.
Mr. Moody- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Congratulations with this wonderful progression. I also like low spreading trees and agree with you that this tree has still a way to go to fulfill your vision. For this moment now the first branch on the right of the trunk on the picture is definitely the sashi-eda and the lowest branch the uke-eda so I will reduce that one because the eye is drawn in two directions. I think this will harmonize the whole. Maybe you have this plan but you're keeping the branch as is for the moment to maximize your nebari development?
As on the very first photos when you started working on the tree you can see that these are two trees fused together so I shall not remove that branch completely myself.
As on the very first photos when you started working on the tree you can see that these are two trees fused together so I shall not remove that branch completely myself.
snobird- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
The BEST progression series I've ever seen. Amazing.
Ryan- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Thankyou for sharing .It goes to show you can take mediocre material and through a little planning turn it in to somthing wonderful good work !!!!!!!
Seth Ellwood- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
.
Last edited by David Cortizas on Fri Dec 18, 2015 4:42 pm; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Excellent --keep the lower left branch-----what happened to the offcut stump
guy ward- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
.
Last edited by David Cortizas on Fri Dec 18, 2015 4:43 pm; edited 2 times in total
Guest- Guest
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
No need for me to chime in really....but I wanted to say thanks. It takes a lot of time to put a progression series like that together but wow....such a great thread and learning opportunity for many of us. I liked the originally tree but I love the current form...thanks again!
Jesse- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
Thank you Sankofabonsai! Very,very interesting about the photos and I like the second tree as well. No need for apologizing for any disagreement because if we discuss the tree the IBC members learn as you mentioned. Especially as you mentioned your vision for the tree and why you are doing development now first and then refining. Congratulations again and thanks for all the photos.
snobird- Member
Re: Ulmus Parvifolia 5 years progression
.
Last edited by David Cortizas on Fri Dec 18, 2015 4:43 pm; edited 1 time in total
Guest- Guest
Page 1 of 5 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Similar topics
» Ulmus parvifolia grove-6 years
» 60€ Ulmus parvifolia neagari progression
» Ulmus Parvifolia
» Shohin Ulmus parvifolia
» Ulmus parvifolia 'Elsmo'
» 60€ Ulmus parvifolia neagari progression
» Ulmus Parvifolia
» Shohin Ulmus parvifolia
» Ulmus parvifolia 'Elsmo'
Page 1 of 5
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|