Corean Hornbeam
+6
BrendanR
tmmason10
abcd
Todd Ellis
Bugeye
jupp
10 posters
Page 1 of 1
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Thank youBugeye wrote:Wow. Stunning fall color. And I also love the pot
jupp- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Hi Jupp
I like your tree in the pot, very nice
I just wonder if the first crossing ower branch do something for the tree...loosing this branch, is the tree also nice as a winterdisplay.
Kind regards Yvonne
I like your tree in the pot, very nice
I just wonder if the first crossing ower branch do something for the tree...loosing this branch, is the tree also nice as a winterdisplay.
Kind regards Yvonne
Guest- Guest
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Just to make sure, after reading/seeing the next post....I am talking about the lowest branch on the maintrunkYvonne Graubaek wrote:Hi Jupp
I like your tree in the pot, very nice
I just wonder if the first crossing ower branch do something for the tree...loosing this branch, is the tree also nice as a winterdisplay.
Kind regards Yvonne
Guest- Guest
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Thanks for your idea abcd. But I would like to receive the double trunk
Last edited by jupp on Wed Dec 04, 2013 6:28 pm; edited 2 times in total
jupp- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
It is not me who are talking about loosing the dubbletrunk...please red.jupp wrote:Thanks for your idea Yvonne. But I would like to receive the double trunkYvonne Graubaek wrote:Just to make sure, after reading/seeing the next post....I am talking about the lowest branch on the maintrunkYvonne Graubaek wrote:Hi Jupp
I like your tree in the pot, very nice
I just wonder if the first crossing ower branch do something for the tree...loosing this branch, is the tree also nice as a winterdisplay.
Kind regards Yvonne
Kind regards Yvonne
Guest- Guest
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Sorry YvonneYvonne Graubaek wrote:It is not me who are talking about loosing the dubbletrunk...please red.jupp wrote:Thanks for your idea Yvonne. But I would like to receive the double trunkYvonne Graubaek wrote:Just to make sure, after reading/seeing the next post....I am talking about the lowest branch on the maintrunkYvonne Graubaek wrote:Hi Jupp
I like your tree in the pot, very nice
I just wonder if the first crossing ower branch do something for the tree...loosing this branch, is the tree also nice as a winterdisplay.
Kind regards Yvonne
Kind regards Yvonne
jupp- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Hi Jupp,
You have a lot of nice trees and you don't need any help, but I was wondering if there are too many branches in a row on the middle of the shorter trunk. It could be a 2d vs. 3d problem but just wanted to see. It is a very nice tree and pot combo as is though.
You have a lot of nice trees and you don't need any help, but I was wondering if there are too many branches in a row on the middle of the shorter trunk. It could be a 2d vs. 3d problem but just wanted to see. It is a very nice tree and pot combo as is though.
tmmason10- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
You know, truncated is quicktmmason10 wrote:Hi Jupp,
You have a lot of nice trees and you don't need any help, but I was wondering if there are too many branches in a row on the middle of the shorter trunk. It could be a 2d vs. 3d problem but just wanted to see. It is a very nice tree and pot combo as is though.
jupp- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
I'd like to see a virt where the top of the main trunk bends away from the lesser trunk. It seems that the two trunks would look more in keeping if they each swept along in the same line, rather than bowing as they grow together?
BrendanR- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
BrendanR wrote:I'd like to see a virt where the top of the main trunk bends away from the lesser trunk. It seems that the two trunks would look more in keeping if they each swept along in the same line, rather than bowing as they grow together?
One likes it that way, another wants it differently.
I like it the way it is.
jupp- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Make no mistake, I really like it as it is.
And I'm not suggesting a change, just curoius what a virt would reveal in terms of the outline. I have seen a few of your trees, and like your approach.
And I'm not suggesting a change, just curoius what a virt would reveal in terms of the outline. I have seen a few of your trees, and like your approach.
BrendanR- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Nice tree, I like it.
Have you considered wiring the lowest left branch of the right trunk to the left & up? It may make the two trunks more "cohesive" but as you said...it depends on your preference.
Have you considered wiring the lowest left branch of the right trunk to the left & up? It may make the two trunks more "cohesive" but as you said...it depends on your preference.
Poink88- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
There seem to be too many twigs & branches emanating from the same point (or vicinity) also. While it helps make the tree look good & full now, it will become a problem later, better to thin it down now and build the remaining primary branches properly to fill the "void" the eliminated branches will leave behind.
I'd probably plant it an inch or 2 deeper as well.
Just trying to help, I hope you do not think of me being too critical. I know it is easier said than done but I really believe these small changes can bump your tree to the next level.
Good luck!
I'd probably plant it an inch or 2 deeper as well.
Just trying to help, I hope you do not think of me being too critical. I know it is easier said than done but I really believe these small changes can bump your tree to the next level.
Good luck!
Poink88- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
jupp wrote:One likes it that way, another wants it differently.
I like it the way it is.
i do too...
and this is a perfect example of the suggested alterations being pleasing mainly to the eye of the suggestors,
while not necessarily benefiting the design of the tree...
it is also a great example of why "judging" of bonsai in a contest is subjective at best and arbitrary at worst.
many trees need alterations (i have a bench full of them )
many trees do not (i have none of this category )
Kevin S - Wisco Bonsai- Member
Re: Corean Hornbeam
Simply wonderful, the color of the leaves is fantastic.
Regards , Daniel
Regards , Daniel
-Daniel-- Member
Similar topics
» What to do with my Hornbeam ?
» Hop-hornbeam
» Too much hornbeam
» A little Hornbeam
» yamadori hornbeam 2010
» Hop-hornbeam
» Too much hornbeam
» A little Hornbeam
» yamadori hornbeam 2010
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|